Everyday we enter into agreements and almost all of these agreements go according as planned. However, inevitably the situation arises where the other party has breached your contract or you have been falsely accused of breaching the contract. When such a situation arises, it is helpful to understand what a breach of contract is and whether it is worth it to pursue such a breach in a Utah court.
What is a Breach of Contract?
A breach of contract occurs when a party to a contract fails to perform to the terms of that contract. Generally a breach of contract is easy to identify but when it comes to litigation it may not be so clear. In a lawsuit the dispute usually comes down to the wording of the contract or whether the parties even entered into a contract. While a contract may have been breached, it may not be worthwhile to sue over that contract unless the breach is "material".
What is a Material Breach?
material breach is a breach so substantial that it causes great damage or justifies the other party's refusal to perform the contract. For example, if Bob agrees to buy a car from Sam for $10,000 but Sam fails to deliver the car to Bob, then Bob is justified in not paying Sam the $10,000. Sam's failure to deliver the car would be an example of a material breach.
In contrast, a non-material breach usually occurs when the damage is slight or non-existent or there is no legitimate excuse for not performing the contract. For instance, Paul agrees to finish painting the exterior of Henry's home by August 1st but only manages to finish the job by August 3rd. Here, although Paul has breached the contract, Henry's damages are minimal (assuming there was no specific reason it needed to be completed by the 1st) and Henry is not justified in refusing to pay Paul (assuming the painting was done as specified). Thus, Paul's breach is non-material.
If a breach is non-material then it usually does not make sense to pursue a breach of contract action. As a result, it is important to determine whether the breach was material and whether there are damages.
What damages can be recovered from a breach of contract?
There are generally two types of recoverable damages available in a breach of contract action: general damages, which flow naturally from the breach, and consequential damages, which are damages that were reasonably foreseeable by the parties at the time the contract was entered into.
General damages are usually easy to identify and recover while consequential damages are more difficult. To recover consequential damages the non-breaching party must prove: the damages were caused by the breach; the amount of damages are reasonably certain; and the damages were within the contemplation of the parties when the contract was entered into. Before pursuing a breach of contract action it is critical that the recoverable damages are identified so that it can be determined whether it is worth it to commence a lawsuit.
If you need help evaluating your breach of contract action, schedule a free consultation with J.Cutler Law.
- May 2, 2017 The Key Benefits of Creating Your Own Business Entity May 2, 2017
- Feb 23, 2017 How To Make Your Sole Proprietorship Legitimate Feb 23, 2017
- Sep 28, 2016 How do I start my own LLC in Utah? Sep 28, 2016
- Aug 24, 2016 Is a corporation the right entity for my new business? Aug 24, 2016
- Aug 23, 2016 Is an LLC the right entity for my new business? Aug 23, 2016
- Aug 20, 2016 Is a partnership the right entity for my new business? Aug 20, 2016
- Aug 19, 2016 Is a sole proprietorship the right entity for my new business? Aug 19, 2016
- Business Law
- Sep 22, 2017 To Sue or Not to Sue Sep 22, 2017
- May 31, 2017 3 Things Every Person Should Know About Small Claims Court May 31, 2017
- Oct 5, 2016 Employee or independent contractor? How to properly classify workers. Oct 5, 2016
- Jun 9, 2017 Should I Hire an Employee or Independent Contractor? Jun 9, 2017
- Jan 24, 2017 5 Things You Should Do To Keep Your Independent Contractor Status Jan 24, 2017
- Nov 3, 2016 A Utah voting leave law that employers and employees need to know Nov 3, 2016
- Oct 28, 2016 Does my business need an employee handbook? Oct 28, 2016
- May 15, 2017 Quick Guide to Music Licensing: An Intro to a Musician's Legal Rights May 15, 2017
- Oct 25, 2016 The National Parks' New Music Video - Stone's Throw Oct 25, 2016
- Jan 11, 2019 Legalese 101: Probate Court Jan 11, 2019
- Dec 6, 2018 Legalese 101: Trusts Dec 6, 2018
- Nov 1, 2017 Three Ways of Distributing Your Children's Inheritance That You Need to Consider Nov 1, 2017
- Sep 29, 2017 Complete Your Estate Plan in 3 Easy Steps! Sep 29, 2017
- Aug 11, 2017 3 Reasons Why You Shouldn't Wait to Make Your Will or Trust Aug 11, 2017
- Jul 26, 2017 Power of Attorney: What You Need to Know Jul 26, 2017
- Jun 15, 2017 The Reason Why You Should Have A Will - Even If You Don't Have Many Assets Jun 15, 2017
- Jun 2, 2017 Beginner's Guide To Completing Your Estate Plan Jun 2, 2017
- Apr 20, 2017 What Everyone Needs to Know About Estate Planning Apr 20, 2017
- Mar 17, 2017 How Do I Know If My Estate Is A Small Estate? Mar 17, 2017
- Mar 1, 2017 Probate Vs. Non-Probate Assets in Estate Planning Mar 1, 2017
- Jan 2, 2017 5 Reasons Why You Should Do Your Estate Plan This Year Jan 2, 2017
- Dec 20, 2016 If I create a living trust, do I still need a will? Dec 20, 2016
- Dec 9, 2016 Do I need a living trust? Dec 9, 2016
- Dec 2, 2016 What is the best way to provide for my children upon my death? Dec 2, 2016
- Nov 15, 2016 Do I need to update my will or trust? Nov 15, 2016
- Nov 2, 2016 Does my will need to be notarized in Utah? Nov 2, 2016
- Oct 10, 2016 What property cannot be left in a will? Oct 10, 2016
- Sep 23, 2016 What is probate and should I try to avoid it? Sep 23, 2016
- Sep 21, 2016 What is a living trust? Sep 21, 2016
- Sep 16, 2016 How To Draft Your Own Will Sep 16, 2016
- Oct 3, 2016 How long does my landlord have to return my security deposit? Oct 3, 2016
Modern Law Firm
- Sep 13, 2016 Are you no longer satisfied with your law firm? Sep 13, 2016
- Jan 19, 2017 4 Buyer Contingencies You Need In Your Home Purchase Agreement Jan 19, 2017
- Oct 21, 2016 How often should the CC&R's of my homeowners' association be updated? Oct 21, 2016
- Oct 18, 2016 How changing ownership of your rental property to an LLC can protect you from liability Oct 18, 2016
- Oct 7, 2016 My neighbor's tree branches and roots are damaging my property, what can I do? Oct 7, 2016
Real Estate Law
- May 19, 2017 Landlord Best Practices: What You Need to Know to Avoid Legal Trouble With Tenants May 19, 2017
- Feb 9, 2017 What To Do With Your Neighbor's Tree Feb 9, 2017