Medicare vs. Medicaid in Utah: What the Five-Year Look-Back Means for Your Assets

Medicare is federal health insurance for people who are 65 or older and for some younger people with disabilities. Medicaid is a needs-based program run by the federal government and the state, and it is the program that pays for long-term nursing home care. Because Medicare does not cover long-term care, families who worry about the cost of a nursing home end up focused on Medicaid, and Medicaid reviews what you gave away during the five years before you apply.

What Legacy Peak does and does not do. Legacy Peak Estate Planning Law does not provide Medicaid planning, Medicaid applications, advice on qualifying for Medicaid, or Medicaid asset protection trusts. This page explains how the programs work so you can understand the rules. If you need help with Medicaid, you can apply through Utah Medicaid or find an elder law attorney through the Utah State Bar's lawyer referral page. The one related service we offer is a Utah asset protection trust, and the sections below explain what it can and cannot do.

What is Medicare?

Medicare is a federal program, so its basic rules are the same in every state. You qualify by age or disability, not by income or assets. Most people become eligible at 65. You can also qualify under 65 if you have received Social Security disability benefits for 24 months, or if you have end-stage renal disease or ALS. Income affects only how much you pay: people with higher incomes pay a higher Part B premium.

Medicare pays for hospital stays, doctor visits and prescriptions, but it has a limit that surprises many families. It does not pay for long-term custodial care, which is help with daily activities such as bathing, dressing and eating. It covers a stay in a skilled nursing facility only when you need skilled care, such as rehabilitation, after a hospital stay of at least three days in a row, for up to 100 days, and you pay a daily share after the first 20 days. After day 100, you pay all of the cost. You can read the details on Medicare's skilled nursing facility page.

What is Medicaid?

Medicaid is a joint program of the federal government and the state, so Utah sets many of its own rules. It is based on need. Some groups qualify on income alone, such as children, pregnant women and low-income adults. But for an older adult who needs long-term nursing home care, Medicaid looks at both income and assets. In Utah, the countable-asset limit is $2,000 for a one-person household (Utah Admin. Code R414-305-3). Some assets are not counted, such as a primary home that meets Utah's conditions, one vehicle and certain burial arrangements. When one spouse needs care, federal rules let the spouse at home keep part of the couple's assets and income.

This is the program that pays for long-term care in a nursing facility, and for certain home and community services that help people stay out of one. That is why asset planning for long-term care is mostly Medicaid planning.

Can you have both Medicare and Medicaid?

Yes. A person who is 65 or older and has limited income and assets can be enrolled in both. Medicare pays first for the services it covers. Medicaid can then help with Medicare premiums and out-of-pocket costs, and it covers care Medicare does not, including long-term nursing home care (CMS dual eligibility categories).

A simple way to keep them apart: Medicare is tied to age or disability. Medicaid is tied to need.

What is the Medicaid five-year look-back?

When someone applies for Medicaid to pay for a nursing home, the state reviews the previous five years (60 months) for gifts and other transfers made for less than fair market value. Under federal law, the five years are counted back from the date the person is both in a nursing facility, or receiving certain home and community services, and has applied for Medicaid (42 U.S.C. § 1396p(c)). Utah applies this rule through its Medicaid program.

If the person gave away assets in that window, Medicaid does not deny the application permanently. It imposes a penalty period during which it will not pay for long-term care. The length of the penalty is the amount transferred divided by the average monthly private-pay cost of a nursing home in the state, and the state may not round the fraction down. For example, if a parent gave a child $50,000 and the state's monthly figure were $10,000, the penalty would be five months. That is an illustration only, because the state sets the real figure and changes it.

The penalty does not start on the day of the gift. It starts when the person would otherwise be eligible for Medicaid and is receiving nursing home care, which is when the person has run out of other money to pay for it. That timing is why a gift that looks small can cause real trouble.

Some transfers are exempt from the penalty. Examples include transfers to a spouse, transfers to a trust solely for a disabled child, a home left to a child who lived there and cared for the parent for at least two years, and transfers into certain trusts for a disabled person under 65. Each exception has conditions, so check before relying on one.

Is there a second look-back after death?

No, although people often think so. The five-year look-back is an eligibility rule that applies when you apply. After a Medicaid recipient dies, a different process called estate recovery applies, and it has no five-year window.

Under Utah Code § 26B-3-1013, Utah may recover the Medicaid it paid for a recipient who was 55 or older. It recovers from the recipient's "recovery estate" and from any trust in which the recipient is both the grantor and a beneficiary. The recovery estate covers more than the probate estate. It includes other property in which the person had a legal interest at death, including property held in joint tenancy, a life estate or a living trust (Utah Code § 26B-3-1001). The statute also says any trust provision that denies recovery is void.

So at death, what matters is what the person still owned or could still benefit from. Recovery is not allowed while a surviving spouse is alive, or if a surviving child is under 21 or is blind or disabled.

A deed signed shortly before death is not a safe way around estate recovery, even though no look-back runs from the date of death. Utah's definition of the recovery estate includes the person's augmented estate (Utah Code § 26B-3-1001), and the augmented estate counts certain transfers made within two years before death, including transfers to any one person that exceed $10,000 in a year (Utah Code § 75-2-205). Utah's Uniform Voidable Transactions Act also lets a creditor ask a court to undo a transfer made to hinder, delay or defraud a creditor, or made for less than reasonably equivalent value by a person who was or became insolvent (Utah Code §§ 25-6-202 and 25-6-203). A creditor generally has four years from the transfer to bring that claim, or one year after discovering a fraudulent transfer if that is later (Utah Code § 25-6-305). And if the person was already receiving Medicaid for long-term care, the transfer rules apply to a home even though the home is not counted as an asset, so giving it away can create a penalty period. Whether the state could undo a particular deed depends on the facts, including who received the home and why.

How asset protection differs for Medicare and Medicaid

Medicare has nothing to qualify for and nothing to recover. It has no asset test, no look-back and no estate recovery. The financial risk is the cost of care Medicare does not cover, such as long-term custodial care. That cost is paid from your own money, or by Medicaid if you qualify, or it becomes a debt owed to a care provider. A Utah domestic asset protection trust (Utah Code § 25-6-502) can protect assets from ordinary creditors, but it is a creditor-protection tool, not a Medicaid tool.

Medicaid planning is about timing and control. Medicaid counts what you own and what you can get from a trust you created. From an irrevocable trust you set up, any portion that could be paid to you counts as available to you (42 U.S.C. § 1396p(d)(3)). That is why a trust that lets you reach the money, including a self-settled asset protection trust, does not help you qualify. Utah can also reach a trust after your death if you were both its grantor and a beneficiary.

Planning that works for Medicaid generally means moving assets out of your name before you need care, either to other people or to an irrevocable trust in which you are not a beneficiary, and then waiting out the 60-month look-back. If you keep a right to income or any other benefit from a trust, you remain a beneficiary, and Utah can still reach the trust after your death. The price is control: you cannot take the assets back. Planning is also limited by timing, because transfers made close to the time you need care cost months of ineligibility. Legacy Peak does not provide Medicaid planning, so if you are considering any of these steps, speak with an elder law attorney before you move an asset.

Who a Utah asset protection trust fits, and who it does not

A Utah domestic asset protection trust is built for a different worry than a nursing home bill. It fits a person with meaningful savings, a business or a professional practice who wants protection from future lawsuits and other creditors and who wants to remain a possible beneficiary of the trust. Utah law lets you create an irrevocable trust for your own benefit that your creditors generally cannot reach, if the trust meets the requirements of Utah Code § 25-6-502.

Only someone who was already your creditor when you funded the Utah domestic asset protection trust can challenge the transfer, and only within the time limits in the statute. Once the trustee pays money out to you, your creditors can reach what you receive. It can also help protect against a large future claim, including an unexpected medical bill that Medicare or insurance does not cover, if the trust is funded while you are healthy and before any such debt exists. It does not help if you rely on Medicaid.

A Utah asset protection trust does not fit every reader of this page. It is not the right tool if you expect to need Medicaid for long-term care, because a trust that can pay you counts as your resource and Utah can recover from it after your death. It is not meant to shield you from a debt or claim you already know about, because the statute requires that you not intend to hinder, delay or defraud a known creditor. And a household with modest assets and no unusual lawsuit risk may find it more than it needs. If your concern is the cost of long-term care, this is not the right trust for it, and Legacy Peak does not provide Medicaid planning, so an elder law attorney is the person to ask.

Frequently asked questions

Does Medicare have a five-year look-back? No. Medicare has no look-back, no asset test and no estate recovery. The look-back belongs to Medicaid.

How far back does Utah Medicaid look? Five years (60 months) before the date you are in a nursing facility, or receiving certain home and community services, and have applied for Medicaid. Transfers for less than fair market value in that period can delay Medicaid payment for long-term care.

Can Medicaid take my house after I die? It can recover from your estate, including a home you still owned or held through a living trust, a joint tenancy or a life estate. Utah cannot recover while a surviving spouse is alive or if a child under 21 or a blind or disabled child survives. What it can reach depends on how the home is held, so ask an elder law attorney before you retitle it.

Will a Utah asset protection trust protect my assets from Medicaid? Not if you can benefit from it. A self-settled trust that could pay money to you counts as an available resource, and Utah can recover from a trust in which you were both grantor and beneficiary. Its strength is protection from ordinary creditors.

Can I give my assets to my children before I need a nursing home? You can, but a gift is a transfer that Medicaid reviews for five years. If you need care within that window, it can delay Medicaid payment. Some transfers are exempt, and an elder law attorney can tell you which apply.

Who should consider a Utah asset protection trust? People with meaningful savings, a business or a professional practice who want protection from future lawsuits and other creditors and who want to remain a possible beneficiary of the trust. It is not a Medicaid planning tool, and it is not meant to protect against a debt or claim you already know about. A short conversation with an attorney can tell you whether it fits your situation.

Can I deed my house to my children right before I die to avoid Medicaid estate recovery? Not safely. A deed signed shortly before death can still be challenged under Utah's augmented estate rules and its voidable transactions law, and a transfer made while receiving Medicaid can create a penalty period. Whether a court would undo a particular deed depends on the facts, so speak with an elder law attorney before you sign anything.

Where to get help

For help with Medicaid, including applications, eligibility and planning for long-term care, you can apply through Utah Medicaid or find an elder law attorney through the Utah State Bar's lawyer referral page. Legacy Peak Estate Planning Law does not offer Medicaid services, so our free consultation cannot help with them.

If your main concern is protecting savings or a business from lawsuits and other creditors, you can read more about Utah asset protection trusts and schedule a free consultation to see whether one fits your situation. Keep in mind the limits described above: a Utah asset protection trust will not help you qualify for Medicaid and does not prevent Medicaid estate recovery.

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Medicaid and Medicare rules change, and how they apply depends on your facts.